Knowledge › Ta'wil & Theology

Ilm al-Asma' wa'l-Sifat — The Divine Names and Attributes: The Central Debate in Islamic Theology Between Tanzih (Transcendence) and the Real Description of God, and the Ismaili Resolution

عِلمُ الأَسمَاءِ وَالصِّفَات — الأَسمَاءُ الإِلَهِيَّةُ وَالصِّفَات: الجَدَلُ المَركَزِيُّ فِي عِلمِ الكَلَامِ الإِسلَامِيِّ بَينَ التَّنزِيهِ وَالوَصفِ الحَقِيقِيِّ لِلهِ وَالحَلُّ الإِسمَاعِيلِيّ
2 min read · 335 words

Ilm al-Asma' wa'l-Sifat (عِلمُ الأَسمَاءِ وَالصِّفَات — The Science of the Divine Names and Attributes; *asma'* — names; *sifat* — attributes, qualities; the branch of Islamic theology dealing with how the 99 [or more] names of God in the Quran and hadith are to be understood: do they describe real qualities in God, are they mere names without inner meaning, or do they point beyond themselves to an absolutely simple divine unity that exceeds all description?) is one of the central and most contested areas of Islamic theology — dividing the Ash'ari, Mu'tazili, Maturidi, Hanbali, and Ismaili schools in fundamental ways.

The Problem

The Quran calls God al-Rahman (the Merciful), al-‘Alim (the All-Knowing), al-Qadir (the All-Powerful), al-Hayy (the Living), and 95 other names. The theological question: are these names descriptions of real qualities in God — qualities distinct from God’s essence — or are they simply names with no additional ontological content beyond the divine essence?

The Schools

Ash’ari: God has real attributes (sifat) — seven essential attributes (life, knowledge, power, will, hearing, sight, speech) — that are neither identical to God’s essence nor other than it. This is a middle position that accepts real attributes while protecting against reducing God to a bundle of distinct qualities.

Mu’tazili: God’s attributes are not additions to His essence; to say God is knowing is to say His essence is such that knowledge applies — not that there is a distinct attribute of knowledge alongside the essence. Protecting divine unity (tawhid) requires rejecting real attributes.

Maturidi: Close to Ash’ari; accepts real attributes with some differences in framing the relationship between attribute and essence.

Hanbali: Takes the Quranic names literally, affirms them of God, and refuses to engage in the philosophical analysis of how they relate to the essence — bila kayf (without asking how).

The Ismaili Resolution: Radical Tanzih

The Ismaili position is the most radical in the direction of tanzih (transcendence):

God (al-Bari’, the Creator) is absolutely beyond all attributes — including the attribute of existence as we understand it. To say “God exists” is already to impose a category on the divine that God transcends. God is not being — God is the source of being.

The divine names in the Quran are therefore not descriptions of God — they are descriptions of the effects of divine action in the world. “God is Merciful” means: mercy flows into the world through the divine chain of guidance, through the Imam’s mediation. The name points toward the mediating chain, not toward a quality in the absolute Creator.

See also: Ismaili Al Aql Al Awwal, Ismaili Cosmology Nafs, Ilm Al Kalam Al Ashari, Tawil Esoteric Interpretation, Ilm Al Falsafa Islamiyya

← All articles
← Previous
al-Harith ibn Hisham — Abu Jahl's Brother Who Converted at the Conquest: How the Son of a Chief Enemy of Islam Became One of Its Most Devoted Servants
Next →
Fiqh al-Waqf al-Mushtarak — The Joint Charitable Endowment in Islamic Law: When Multiple Beneficiaries Share a Single Waqf and How Their Interests Are Managed
✦

More in Ta'wil & Theology

Ta'wil — The Inner Meaning of the Quran

Ta'wil is the esoteric, inner interpretation of the Quran unique to the Ismaili Fatimi tradition. Every verse has an outer (zahir) and an inner (batin) meaning, accessible only through the living Imam and his representative the Dai.
Dua Jawshan al-Kabir — The Great Armour

Jawshan al-Kabir is a profound supplication of 100 sections containing 1000 names and attributes of Allah. Narrated through Imam Ali ibn al-Husain (AS), it is recited during the blessed nights of Ramadan and is among the greatest duas in the Shia Ismaili tradition.
Asas and Natiq — The Speaker and the Foundation

In the Ismaili ta'wil tradition, every Prophet (Natiq — the Speaking Prophet) who brings a new divine law is paired with a silent Asas (Foundation) who carries the inner, esoteric meaning of the revelation. The Prophet Muhammad (SAW) is the Natiq of Islam; Imam Ali ibn Abi Talib (AS) is his Asas. This pairing is among the most foundational concepts in Fatimid-Tayyibi theology.
← Back to all articles